It is our hope that this book will be an exciting adventure for the reader, as it was exciting for those of us who have lived through it and are living through it now. In a sense it is historical because it deals with the period from about 1960 to the present. However, it also seeks to capture the nature of the researchers’ experiences in the development and elaboration of their research and applied interests. In the academic world, we often talk in terms of how our early intellectual interests and training influenced the kinds of research issues and questions we study, the theoretical approaches we test, and the methods that we use to deal with these issues and questions. However, this is only partly true. The actual process is somewhat different and the events that occur to guide us are not always as technical as they sound, and these events and their ramifications are what makes it very exciting.
The book will describe how we started out in our respective research careers by providing some of the early finding from our respective research efforts dealing with the relationships of traditional demographic variables such as age, education, occupation, race, marital status, migration, social mobility, etc., to psychological health measures of various kinds and to subjective evaluations of quality of life; and how migration and social mobility emerged as fundamental issues to be dealt with in this process.
The process begins with our early findings which were quite different from the general thinking and data in the several social science disciplines, i.e., “serendipitous” or unexpected findings. These findings led us to re-think the definitions, the explanations of the earlier findings, and reevaluate the methods that prevailed. From these efforts, new thinking and explanations were required. It also resulted in new research with these new insights and new methods that were appropriate for evaluating the new thinking. In more technical terms, we were looking for new theories and explanatory models to account for the findings; and we needed revised or different research methods for evaluating them.
The Full Book PDF |
|
Front Matter |
|
Part I |
|
Chapter 1 A Perspective on Basic and Applied Research: Why It Is Necessary |
|
1.1 Definitional Issue
|
|
1.2 Origins of and Current Consequences of the “Applied” and “Basic” Distinction
|
|
1.3 Our View of the Issue
|
|
1.4 Multiple Realities
|
|
Chapter 2 Changing Character of Migration Research: New Theoretical Models and New Research Methods Required in the Transition from Experimental to Cross–Cultural Perspectives |
|
2.1 Early Explanations
|
|
2.2 The Strategies to Explain Inconsistencies
|
|
2.3 What Constitutes a “Case”
|
|
2.4 Sense of “Quality of Life” and “Well–Being” in Defining “Caseness”
|
|
2.5 Migration and the Issue of Definition
|
|
2.6 Traditional Experimental and Cross–Cultural Perspectives: Relevance and Implications
|
|
2.7 The Economics and Feasibility of Changing Demands
|
|
2.8 The Issue of Incidence and Prevalence Studies
|
|
2.9 Nature of Causal Explanations
|
|
Chapter 3 Traditional Experimental and Cross–Cultural Perspectives: Relevance and Implications |
|
3.1 Redefinition of “Migration” and Its Ramifications
|
|
Chapter 4 Classical Studies: Early Studies of Migration and Mental Illness (Based on Hospital Admissions) |
|
4.1 Early Empirical Perspective
|
|
4.2 International Migration
|
|
4.3 Internal Migration or In–Migration (Empirically Interchangeable)
|
|
4.4 What Can We Learn from the Early Studies?
|
|
Chapter 5 Concepts, Theories and Hypotheses |
|
5.1 New Theoretical Perspective
|
|
5.2 Stress
|
|
5.3 Coping
|
|
5.4 Social Environment, Stress and Mental Health
|
|
Part II |
|
Chapter 6 Studies That Changed Our Perspective: Illustrative Serendipity Findings and Proposed Explanations |
|
6.1 Ramifications of Serendipity Findings
|
|
6.2 Migration and Social Mobility: The Case of the United States
|
|
6.2.1 Migration
|
|
6.2.2 Social (Status) Mobility
|
|
6.3 Migration, Social Mobility and Mental Disorder: The Case of Norway
|
|
6.4 Preliminary Explanatory “Hypotheses”
|
|
6.5 Insights from Case Histories
|
|
6.6 Transient Migration (Commuting) and Risk of Mental Disorder in Norway
|
|
6.7 Migration, Cultural Change and Psychological Health
|
|
6.8 “Culture Shock”
|
|
6.8.1 The Influence of Gender in the Migration Experience
|
|
6.8.2 Acculturation and Psychological Health in Young People
|
|
6.8.3 Differences Between Ethnic Groups
|
|
Chapter 7 Proposed Theoretical Approaches to Understanding Psychological Health Status: The Social and Interpersonal Models of Psychological Disorders |
|
7.1 Anomie, Alienation and Social Network Models
|
|
7.2 Social Networks as Support Systems and Buffers: Linkage to Psychological Health Status
|
|
7.3 The Socio-Cultural Integration of Local Communities
|
|
7.4 Social Interaction/Social Network Stress and Psychological Health Status
|
|
7.5 Perception and Reality of Social Structural Integration Among African–American and White Adolescent Networks
|
|
7.6 Role Models, Network Consensus and Juvenile Delinquency
|
|
Chapter 8 Proposed Theoretical Approaches to Understanding Psychological Health Status3 |
|
8.1 Rethinking Definitions of Psychological Health
|
|
8.2 Theoretical Orientation
|
|
8.3 Macro Sociological and Social–Psychological Origins
|
|
8.4 Micro Sociological and Social–Psychological Origins
|
|
8.5 Conceptual Definitions
|
|
8.6 Modification and Application of the Resultant Weighted Valence Theory
|
|
8.7 The Social and Interpersonal Models of Psychological Disorders
|
|
Chapter 9 International Migration, In–Migration and Social Mobility: A Comprehensive Theoretical Approach |
|
9.1 Systematic Definitions of Social and Individual Movements
|
|
9.2 Comprehensive Theory of International Migration and In–Migration
|
|
9.2.1 Is it Important to Know the Values and Norms of the Cultural Context from Which the Migrant Came to Explain Psychological Health Status?
|
|
9.2.2 Is the Nature of the Communication Between the Migrant and His/Her Parents to the Family Important Factors in His/Her Psychological Health Status?
|
|
9.2.3 Is It Important to Know with Whom the Migrant Moved?
|
|
9.3 “Comprehensive Theory” of Social Mobility
|
|
9.4 Implications of “Socio-Cultural Change” Theoretical Perspective
|
|
Part III |
|
Chapter 10 Methodological Problems and Issues in Comparative Urban Research and/or Cross–Cultural Urban Research |
|
10.1 Emerging Methodological Issues
|
|
10.2 Dimensions of Cross–Cultural Analyses and Comparative Urban Studies
|
|
10.3 The Meaning of “Urban” Research and Current Limitations
|
|
10.4 What Makes Urban Data Valuable
|
|
10.5 The Meaning of Comparability of Data Sets
|
|
Chapter 11 Development and Evaluation of a Cross–Cultural Approach to Migration: Nigeria and Israel |
|
11.1 Ramifications for Cross-Cultural Research
|
|
11.2 Direction of Migration
|
|
11.3 Age of Migrants
|
|
11.4 Occupation and Migration
|
|
11.5 Education of Migrants3
|
|
11.6 Functional and Conflict Theoretical Issues in Developing Approaches to the Problem
|
|
11.7 Migration, Urbanism and Psychological Condition (Psychoneurotic Symptom Scores or PNS)
|
|
11.7.1 Migratory Status and PNS
|
|
11.7.2 Urbanism and PNS
|
|
11.7.3 Interaction of Migration with Urbanism and PNS
|
|
11.8 Place of Migration and Urbanism in Openness of the Opportunity Structure
|
|
11.8.1 Hypothesis: Migration Flows from Objectively Closed Systems to Relatively Open Systems
|
|
11.8.2 Hypothesis: From a Subjective Perspective, Migration Flows from Perceived Closed Systems to Perceived Open Systems
|
|
11.8.3 How Redundant are Status Opportunity Structure and Economic Security?
|
|
11.9 Migration, Urbanism, Relative Economic Security: Perception of Economic Security
|
|
11.9.1 Hypothesis: Migration Flows from a Relatively Objective Insecure System to a Relatively Objective Secure Economical System
|
|
11.9.2 Hypothesis: Migration Flows from a Perceived Economically Insecure System to a Perceived Economically Secure Systems
|
|
11.10 Evaluation of Hypotheses Based on Interrelationship of Anomie and Perception of Anomie: Nigeria
|
|
11.11 Evaluation of Hypotheses Based on the Interrelationship of Objective Economic Insecurity and Perception of Economic Security: Israel
|
|
Chapter 12 Network Analyses in Urban Research: New Perspectives |
|
12.1 Overview of the Problem
|
|
12.2 New Research Strategies
|
|
12.3 One Specific Strategy
|
|
12.4 The First Findings and Their Meaning
|
|
12.5 Social Networks and Psychological Impairment in Urban Research: One Alternative Approach to the Urban Environment
|
|
12.5.1 Emerging Approach to Urban Research
|
|
12.5.2 Theoretical Perspective
|
|
12.5.3 Definition of Psychological Impairment
|
|
12.5.4 Description of the Study
|
|
12.5.5 Major Substantive Findings
|
|
12.5.6 Discussion and Implications
|
|
12.6 Epidemiology of Opportunities for Social Interaction and Psychological Health Status: New Horizons
|
|
12.6.1 Role of Epidemiology in Social Research
|
|
12.6.2 Impetus for New Research
|
|
12.6.3 Psychological Health Status
|
|
12.6.4 Clarification of the Meaning of “Risk Factors”
|
|
12.6.5 Study Parameters
|
|
12.6.6 Sources of Data
|
|
12.6.7 Potential for Generating Testable Hypotheses
|
|
Chapter 13 Migration, Cultural Change and Psychological Health |
|
13.1 “Culture Shock”
|
|
13.2 The Influence of Gender in the Migration Experience
|
|
13.3 Acculturation and Psychological Health in Young People
|
|
13.4 Differences Between Ethnic Groups
|
|
Chapter 14 A Formal Theory of Migration and the Predictive Potential Multiple Reality Approach |
|
14.1 The Need for a Formal Theory for Predicting Social Outcomes
|
|
14.2 Assumptions Underlying the Model
|
|
14.3 The Predictive Potential of the Formal Model for Predicting the Migration Decision and the Decision’s Effects
|
|
14.4 Involuntary Migration
|
|
Chapter 15 Small Group Tradition in Social Therapeutic Modalities in Psychiatry |
|
15.1 Reintroduction of Small Group Traditions in Psychiatry
|
|
15.2 Social Rehabilitation in the Psychiatric Hospital–Field Experiment (USA)
|
|
15.3 Rehabilitation Moves into the Community–Field Experiment (USA)
|
|
15.4 Small Group or Social Network Studies in Norway
|
|
15.4.1 The Vinderen Study
|
|
15.4.2 Changing Properties of Small Social Networks in Treatment of Psychiatric Patients and in Prevention of Psychological Disorders Among High Risk People
|
|
15.4.3 The Intervention Project
|
|
15.5 Understanding Change in the Two Network Experiments (Kleiner et al 4)
|
|
Part IV |
|
Chapter 16 Community Health Profile: A Tool for Community Development and Prevention of Psychiatric Problems |
|
16.1 Community Diagnoses and/or Community Profiles for Planning of Mental Health Prevention/Promotion and Development of Psychiatric Services–Some Evidence from Norway
|
|
16.2 Migration and Mental Health in Community Health Profiles
|
|
16.3 Mental Health Promotion
|
|
16.4 Community Mental Health Profile
|
|
16.4.1 The Village Case: Problems When a Great Proportion of the Population Leaves the Community
|
|
16.4.2 “Coastal” Compared with “Rural Inland”
|
|
16.4.3 Forced Migration and Mental Health
|
|
16.5 Intent of Mental Health Intervention
|
|
16.6 A National Health Indicator System
|
|
Chapter 17 The Mental Health of In–Migrants and Natives in a Community Perspective |
|
17.1 Migratory Status in Lofoten
|
|
17.1.1 Introduction
|
|
17.1.2 Theoretical Roots
|
|
17.1.3 Population–The Context of the Study
|
|
Chapter 18 Migration, Urbanism, Life Events and Psychological Status |
|
18.1 Significance of Life Events
|
|
18.2 Community Studies, Migration and Psychological Health Status
|
|
18.2.1 Migration, Life Events, Psychological Health and Well-Being
|
|
18.2.2 Migratory Status, Yield in Life Events and Outcome Measures
|
|
18.2.3 Migratory Status, Life Events and Outcome Measures
|
|
18.3 Structural Differences Between Migratory Status Groups and Potency of Life Events
|
|
18.4 Problematic Social and Interpersonal Life Events and Mental Health and Quality of Life by Migratory Status
|
|
18.5 Social Support/Integration, Social Network Index, HSCL25 and Cantril Index
|
|
18.6 Cumulative Effects of Age, Sex, Life Events and Social Indices on Outcome Measures by Migratory Status
|
|
Chapter 19 The Community Intervention Strategy: Strategies for the Mobilization and Use of Community Resources for Psychological Health and Well–Being as Part of Treatment, Prevention and Planning |
|
19.1 Community Psychiatry
|
|
19.2 Multiple Realities Model
|
|
19.3 Planning for Community Proximal to Psychiatric Health Services
|
|
19.3.1 Community Psychiatric Responsibility
|
|
19.3.2 The Strategic Network Model
|
|
19.3.3 Using the Strategic Network Model
|
|
19.4 Mental Health Promotion with a Local Community Focus
|
|
19.5 The Accessibility Project
|
|
19.6 Added Observations from the Community Projects
|
|
19.7 Multiple Realities in an Applied Perspective
|
|
19.8 Concluding Remarks
|
|
Chapter 20 Crossing Boundaries and Psychological Health: Implications for Research, Planning and Intervention |
|
20.1 The Role of Explanatory Theories of Psychological Disorders and Sense of Well–Being
|
|
20.2 Origins of Insights and Their Impact on New Thinking
|
|
20.3 Emerging Focus on the “Community”
|
|
20.4 Importance of Mobility: Migration in Particular
|
|
20.5 The Meaning of “Boundaries” and Their Significance for Understanding Psychological Health and Quality of Life
|
|
References |
|
Topical Index |
|
Back Matter |
|
Origin of the International Team of Authors
Prior to 1969, Dr. Kleiner was involved in major research funded by American funding sources including the National Institute of Mental Health. During those same years, Drs. Dalgard (now deceased) and Sorensen were also involved in major research funded by Norwegian sources, including the Norwegian Research Council. In 1969, Dr. Kleiner came to Norway as a Research Professor, funded by both American (including Fulbright) and Norwegian (including the Norwegian Research Council) funding sources.
In 1969, the three researchers first met and immediately found that their theoretical and research interests overlapped dramatically; they immediately began forty-one years of collaboration in research and publications. In the l980s and l990s, much of their research was in Norway and funded, in the main, by Norwegian sources. This included Dr. Kleiner working at the Center for Social Network and Health at Ulleval Hospital during the 1990-1991 academic year.
However, during this period, their research has also included, at various times, psychological health, juvenile delinquency, suicide, crime, subjective quality of life (or sense of well-being), general health issues, twin studies and mental disorder, etc. Here they will use the concepts of psychological health status and felt quality of life as the main outcome concepts, and the various operational definitions of the outcome measures used in the intervening years will be subsumed under these concepts.
During the early years, they were primarily concerned with traditional epidemiological studies in which correlation studies were made relating demographic variables such as migratory status, social mobility, and ethnicity to incidence and prevalence of the various individual and social problems of interest to them, individually or collectively at the time. As these efforts developed and expanded, it became more and more evident that their assumptions and others’ assumptions as well about the meanings and importance of such variables were highly questionable.
In the process, variables were defined more precisely which had major implications for their significance and for the task of the researcher. This required the researcher to learn about the social and cultural properties of the locus of socialization, learn about the socialization process itself, and the meaning of the relevant variables and experiences to those experiencing them.. The theoretical origins and influences on their thinking derive from the pioneering and seminal work of Kurt Lewin and Alexander Leighton (a student of Adolph Meyer).
This book is for all those in the different social sciences and service disciplines that are interested in social and psychological problems that need to be studied and acted upon, i.e., the merger of ‘basic’ and ‘applied’ orientations. That is also why the title includes ‘Psychological Problems and Intervention.’ The book is also for those policy makers, administrators in health related governmental and community agencies, and community leaders that are interested in dealing constructively with these problems in their areas of concern. For a few people interested in migration, social mobility, and social change as intellectual issues of interest, these issues are important and need to be included in any historical-sociological-anthropological-psychological-political-economic projects of some scope and magnitude. We also feel it is important to take the time to raise some of the issues, and then show how we dealt with them, and with what success.